Given that both have missed significant time recently, Keefe needs to decide whether or not the team need time together to gel ahead of the playoffs, or whether health and rest is more important. If he does decide to bench Matthews, it could turn out to be a masterstroke, but given all of the pressure on this team, any decision he makes could backfire unless this team have a deep run.
For now though, all NHL fans, even ones that don't like the Maple Leafs should gear up for a historic chase from Auston Matthews, and whether or not it's the right move for the team, it would be hard to not be disappointed if he decided to take Matthews out of the lineup with 70 goals firmly in reach.